RNfinity
Research Infinity Logo, Orange eye of horus, white eye of Ra
  • Home
  • Submit
    Research Articles
    Ebooks
  • Articles
    Academic
    Ebooks
  • Info
    Home
    Subject
    Submit
    About
    News
    Submission Guide
    Contact Us
    Personality Tests
  • Login/sign up
    Login
    Register

Physics Maths Engineering

Limitations of Meta-analyses of Studies With High Heterogeneity

rnfinity

info@rnfinity.com

orcid logo

Peter B. Imrey

Peter B. Imrey

Department of Quantitative Health Sciences, Lerner Research Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio


  Peer Reviewed

copyright icon

© attribution CC-BY

  • 0

rating
516 Views

Added on

2024-10-22

Doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.19325

Related Subjects
Physics
Math
Chemistry
Computer science
Engineering
Earth science
Biology

Abstract

Sabitova et al have performed an important service in compiling and summarizing 2 decades of studies on job burnout and satisfaction among physicians and dentists in middle-income countries and a few low-income countries. The authors followed a standard approach to performing a systematic review and meta-analysis to analyze studies that assessed job-related morale among physicians and dentists working in these countries, using levels of job burnout, job satisfaction, and job motivation as indicators of job morale. Data were extracted independently by several investigators following the Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) reporting guidelines.

Key Questions and Answers

1. What is the significance of high heterogeneity in meta-analyses?

High heterogeneity in meta-analyses suggests that the studies being combined differ substantially in design, populations, or outcomes, making it difficult to draw meaningful conclusions from the pooled results.

2. How does random-effects meta-analysis handle heterogeneity?

Random-effects meta-analysis assumes that the studies come from different populations and calculates a distribution of effects rather than a single "true" effect. This approach increases the uncertainty of results in the presence of high heterogeneity.

3. What challenges arise from unexplained heterogeneity in studies?

Unexplained heterogeneity complicates the interpretation of meta-analytic results, as differences in study conditions, participant characteristics, and measurement methods may obscure the overall trends.

The study discusses the challenges posed by high heterogeneity in meta-analyses, particularly when combining studies with diverse populations, conditions, and measurements. It highlights how random-effects models address variability but may still produce uncertain results when heterogeneity is substantial. The analysis of burnout among physicians and dentists across various countries illustrates how regional differences and study variability complicate the interpretation of meta-analytic outcomes. Despite rigorous methodology, these challenges limit the precision and generalizability of conclusions drawn from such analyses.

4. How does geographic region affect the interpretation of meta-analysis results?

Geographic region may influence burnout rates, but regional comparisons in meta-analysis can be misleading if the studies are not representative or are clustered in a few countries.

Summary Video Not Available

Review 0

Login

ARTICLE USAGE


Article usage: Oct-2024 to May-2025
Show by month Manuscript Video Summary
2025 May 143 143
2025 April 81 81
2025 March 66 66
2025 February 45 45
2025 January 63 63
2024 December 44 44
2024 November 53 53
2024 October 21 21
Total 516 516
Show by month Manuscript Video Summary
2025 May 143 143
2025 April 81 81
2025 March 66 66
2025 February 45 45
2025 January 63 63
2024 December 44 44
2024 November 53 53
2024 October 21 21
Total 516 516
Related Subjects
Physics
Math
Chemistry
Computer science
Engineering
Earth science
Biology
copyright icon

© attribution CC-BY

  • 0

rating
516 Views

Added on

2024-10-22

Doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.19325

Related Subjects
Physics
Math
Chemistry
Computer science
Engineering
Earth science
Biology

Follow Us

  • Xicon
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

5 Braemore Court, London EN4 0AE, Telephone +442082758777

© Copyright 2025 All Rights Reserved.